Boom or Bust? Managing Expectations for Concentrated Positions and Risk (Executive Summary)
Simge Ulucam, Harrison Selwitz, and Lisa R. Goldberg
Investors holding concentrated stock portfolios are exposed to company-specific risk, which has been associated with a high rate of catastrophic loss in the past. Diversification of the concentrated stock to a portfolio that tracks a broad market index reduces company-specific risk and may be beneficial even if liquidation of the position has an up-front tax cost. These conclusions are based on a comprehensive study of stocks that were members of the Russell 3000® Index at any time between December 31, 1986, and February 28, 2022.
For some investors, holding a concentrated stock portfolio was a boom-or-bust experience. Nearly 40% of stocks in the index faced a catastrophic loss, meaning a loss of more than half of their peak values without recovery. Catastrophic loss was prevalent across sectors with at least 30% of stocks in most sectors experiencing such a loss. Although companies of all sizes and market sensitivities carried this risk, smaller companies and those with higher market betas had a higher chance of catastrophic loss.
While most stocks underperformed the index, a few spectacularly outperformed. Within their respective lifetimes, only 34% of securities saw returns better than the index and only a small portion of those exhibited extreme outperformance, offering the rare chance for a big payoff on a relatively small investment when the share price rose significantly. Stocks that were in the top decile, as sorted by their lifetime cumulative returns over the index, had excess returns of more than 6,000%, on average.
An investor holding a concentrated position may wonder about what to expect in the future. Historically, past winners did not keep winning. Portfolios consisting of the 25 top outperformers over a 10-year period, on average, underperformed the index over the next 10 years. Among the headline stocks that were once extreme winners are several of history’s biggest losers, with examples including Yahoo! (collapsed and never regained its dot-com highs); Sun Microsystems (was more than 95% off its peak value), Sears (lost nearly all its starting value), and GE (experienced several bouts of catastrophic losses).
An assortment of diversification techniques offer protection from catastrophic risk while allowing investors who would like to keep a stake in a concentrated position to do so. Our study shows that reducing the level of single-stock concentration up-front through partial liquidation and investing the proceeds in the index lowered the downside risk associated with the overall investment. In addition, given that individual securities typically underperformed the index, at lower concentration levels, their relative weights in the portfolio naturally declined and with that, the likelihood of a catastrophic loss for the overall portfolio.
For taxable investors, liquidating a concentrated stock can pose a significant tax hurdle, especially if it is highly appreciated. Diversification may still be beneficial for such an investor. Given that the median security lagged the index by more than 5% per year during our study period, a typical investor would have offset the liquidation tax cost by investing the after-tax proceeds from the liquidation in the index for six years, based on our stated assumptions.
Although diversifying a portfolio does not guarantee profit or protect against investment loss or market volatility, reducing the level of single-stock concentration can lower the downside risk associated with that position. Given the general tendency of single stocks to underperform the market historically (including facing unrecoverable catastrophic losses), investors would be prudent to shift their focus to manage risk, diversify, and avoid the boom-or-bust experience.
To learn more about the risks associated with a concentrated stock position and how diversifying might mitigate them, read our complete “Boom or Bust?” paper.
Aperio is providing this link to a third-party website that displays a research report, article, webcast, video, or other content that we believe may be informational or educational for you. This linked content is presented by a source that we believe to be reliable, but we do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness, including any associated disclosures. Aperio has no control over the nature of the content on, or the availability of, this third-party website.
The inclusion of this link on our website also does not imply a recommendation or endorsement of any views expressed in such linked content and should not be considered: investment, tax, or legal advice; a solicitation; a recommendation of Aperio or any third-party’s services; or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction.
Your subscription to the Aperio Blog has been confirmed. You will receive an email notification when a new blog is posted.
Your password is now updated.
Thank you for setting the security questions for your account.
User Must Be Logged In
You must be logged in to perform this action.
Invalid token. Please reload the page and try this action again.
You Currently Do Not Have Portal Access
You do not have access to the Aperio Client Portal.
Please note that if you just registered, it may take up to 24 hours after your registration form has been approved before you are able to log in.
That answer does not match our records. Note that responses to security questions are case sensitive. Please try again or contact Aperio at email@example.com or 415.339.4590.
Your portal user profile does not have provide access to this page. Please contact your administrator if you believe you have receieved this message in error.
Please select a request type.
Your account is temporarily locked because you repeatedly entered wrong answers to security question. Please try again in an hour.
There was an error sending the email to your new user. Please try again.
There was an error sending your email. Please try again.
There was an error sending the email to reset your password. Please try again.
There was an error sending the verification email for your portal account. Please press “Send Verification Email” to retry.
There was an error sending your Contact Us form to Aperio. Please try again.
Would you like to set up Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) for your account? If yes, click here. If not, you are able to enable MFA for your account at anytime in your Profile by clicking Edit Profile.
With Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), an extra layer of security is added to your account to prevent unauthorized users from logging in, even if they have your password. This extra security measure requires you to verify your identity using a randomized code we will send you each time you attempt to log in. MFA reduces the risk of unauthorized requests from your Aperio Client Portal account and provides extra security for your data.
You can choose to receive your security code through one of three ways: by text message/SMS, voice call, or the Okta Verify app. Through Aperio’s partnership with Okta, you can access their free Verify app to receive your MFA token on your Apple or Android device.
Are you sure you want to remove this factor from your account?
The factor has been successfully removed from your account.
You are enrolled in SMS MFA.
You are not enrolled in Text/SMS MFA. To learn how to enroll, click here.
To enroll in SMS MFA, please enter your mobile phone number.
Enter the code received on your mobile phone below.
You have successfully enrolled in SMS MFA.
This phone number was previously set up for SMS MFA for this account. The number and your portal account are now re-enrolled in SMS MFA. If this is incorrect, please contact Aperio at 415.339.4590.
You are enrolled in Voice Call MFA.
You are not enrolled in Voice MFA. To learn how to enroll, click here.
To enroll in Voice MFA, please enter your number and extension if applicable.
Enter the code from the automated voice call you just received.
You have successfully enrolled in Voice MFA.
You are enrolled in Okta Verify MFA.
You are not enrolled in Okta Verify MFA. To learn more on Okta Verify MFA, visit the Okta Verify enrollment guide here.
Please ensure you have downloaded the Okta Verify App prior to clicking Enroll.
After opening the Okta Verify App on your mobile device, press Add Account and scan the QR code shown on the screen. Enter the code shown in the app in the box below.
You have successfully enrolled in Okta Verify MFA.